Aloha! Suzzane & Jessica!
Firstly, i so feel like booking one in Muskoka. Pretty nice, sane, friendly, grand, peaceful and fun place it is, the way i see it in the brochure and leaflets that you've attached. And i read somewhere that even Cindy Crawford spent some time there, sweet!
As per my observation of the material that you attached, they are informative, yes, but it can be more wow for sure, it can be made different for sure, we can play with the colors. And i totally understood the main issue, you need a regular-single-clear 'grid'!
A grid is something that you apply on each and every single advertising platform. One thing that i am not sure about, how do you want it to be seen? As a 'fun fun' side or as a 'corporate side', the imagery?
I'll be happy to work on this, wouldn't want ever to rush through the work, your logo should be fun and totally friendly, real estate is all about being friends, right? May be a scribble and that's it. I don't think we even need a Map there of Muskoka? Just thinking.
I like the typography of 'You deserve the best', Discover the best with My Muskoka!
The overall layout and design can be improved by far.
I think it should be a mix of fun/explore & corporate feel/design.
Let me know if i can be of your help, anytime.
Cheers,
Aim.